Which is better: Gusto or ADP?

Gusto is better for small businesses and startups that want affordable, easy-to-use payroll and HR. ADP Workforce Now is better for mid-market and enterprise companies that need advanced HR, compliance, reporting, and scalability across many employees and locations.

How much does ADP cost?

ADP pricing is custom. ADP Workforce Now typically starts around $150 to $500 per month as a base fee, plus per-employee charges, and may include implementation fees. Businesses should request a quote based on their specific payroll, HR, and benefits needs.

Is Gusto cheaper than ADP?

Yes, Gusto is generally cheaper than ADP for small businesses. Gusto Simple starts at $40 per month plus $6 per employee, while ADP Workforce Now is quote-based and typically costs more, especially after setup and add-on modules.

When should a business switch from Gusto to ADP?

Businesses usually switch from Gusto to ADP when they outgrow simple payroll and need enterprise-grade HR, benefits, compliance, multi-state or global payroll, advanced reporting, and dedicated support. This often happens around 100 to 150 employees or when workforce complexity increases significantly.

What is the best online payroll service for small businesses?

Gusto is one of the best online payroll services for small businesses because of its simple setup, transparent pricing, and all-in-one payroll, benefits, and HR features. For larger or more complex organizations, ADP Workforce Now is a stronger fit.

Independent comparison · Updated 1970

Gusto vs ADP (1970)

Gusto and ADP are two of the most popular online payroll services in the market. Gusto is built for small businesses that want payroll, benefits, and basic HR in one simple platform. ADP Workforce Now is built for larger organizations that need scalable payroll, compliance, and workforce management. This guide breaks down pricing, features, and the right time to switch.

Get a personalized payroll shortlist Best payroll software

Quick verdict

Choose Gusto if…

Fit 94

You have 1–100 employees and want simple, affordable payroll

You need benefits, onboarding, and PTO without a complex HR platform

You prefer a modern, self-service setup that takes days, not weeks

You want transparent online payroll pricing with no long-term contract

Choose ADP if…

Fit 91

You have 100+ employees or complex, multi-state payroll

You need advanced HR, recruiting, benefits, and compliance support

You want dedicated support, custom reporting, and enterprise integrations

You have the budget and team capacity for a longer implementation

Gusto vs ADP comparison

Category	Gusto	ADP Workforce Now	Edge
Best fit	Small businesses and startups (1–100 employees) that want simple payroll	Mid-market and enterprise (100+ employees) with complex HR and payroll needs	Tie
Starting price	Simple: $40/mo + $6/employee; Plus: $80/mo + $12/employee; Premium: custom	Custom quote; typically $150–$500+/mo base + per-employee fees; setup fees common	Gusto
Payroll processing	Full-service payroll, auto-tax filing, direct deposit, unlimited payroll runs	Full-service payroll with robust tax compliance, garnishments, and multi-state support	Tie
HR & compliance features	Hiring, onboarding, PTO, benefits admin, and basic compliance tools	Advanced HR, benefits, talent management, recruiting, and compliance at scale	ADP
Benefits administration	Health, dental, vision, 401(k), workers' comp, and commuter benefits through licensed brokers	Comprehensive benefits packages, insurance, retirement, and integrated COBRA administration	ADP
Time & attendance	Time tracking included in Plus and Premium; basic scheduling and PTO	Advanced time and labor management, scheduling, and compliance-ready reporting	ADP
Reporting & analytics	Clean, easy-to-read reports; limited custom reporting on lower tiers	Deep reporting, custom dashboards, and workforce analytics for leadership	ADP
Integrations	Popular accounting, POS, and HR tools; strong QuickBooks and Xero support	Massive integration ecosystem with ERP, HRIS, accounting, and workforce platforms	ADP
Ease of use	Modern, intuitive UI designed for non-HR experts; quick setup	Powerful but more complex; often requires training and an admin owner	Gusto
Implementation effort	Self-serve setup in hours or days; onboarding support available	Typically weeks to months; guided implementation with an ADP specialist	Gusto
Scalability	Great for growing SMBs up to roughly 100–150 employees	Built to scale to thousands of employees across multiple states and countries	ADP
Customer support	Phone, email, and chat; strong reputation for SMB support	24/7 support, dedicated account managers, and large-enterprise service tiers	Tie

Pricing and total cost of ownership

Gusto

Simple — $40/mo + $6/employee. Full-service payroll, benefits, and basic hiring.

Plus — $80/mo + $12/employee. Adds time tracking, PTO, project tracking, and more HR tools.

Premium — Custom pricing. Adds dedicated support, HR resources, and compliance features.

Contractor-only — $0/mo + $6/contractor for businesses that pay only contractors.

No setup fees; transparent pricing listed online; month-to-month plans available.

ADP Workforce Now

Base fee — Custom quote; typically starts around $150–$500/mo depending on company size and modules.

Per-employee fee — Added charge for each employee or contractor on payroll.

Add-on modules — Time & attendance, benefits administration, recruiting, learning, and analytics.

Implementation — One-time setup and data migration fees are common; larger rollouts may require a specialist.

Pricing is quote-based; most businesses need an ADP sales consultation for an exact figure.

Gusto — pros & cons

Pros

Transparent, affordable pricing for small businesses
Fast, self-service setup and modern user experience
All-in-one payroll, benefits, and basic HR
Unlimited payroll runs and strong tax compliance
Excellent QuickBooks and Xero integrations

Cons

Limited advanced HR and reporting features
Less scalable beyond 100–150 employees
No dedicated account manager on lower tiers
Time and attendance only on higher tiers
Customer support can be slower during busy periods

ADP — pros & cons

Pros

Scales to thousands of employees across states and countries
Deep HR, benefits, compliance, and talent management features
Robust reporting, analytics, and custom dashboards
Large integration ecosystem and dedicated enterprise support
Decades of payroll expertise and 24/7 support options

Cons

Higher total cost and quote-based pricing
Longer implementation and steeper learning curve
Can feel complex for small teams with simple needs
Add-on modules can increase cost quickly
May require an internal admin or HR specialist

When to switch from Gusto to ADP

Headcount threshold

Consider ADP around 100–150 employees. Gusto works well for smaller teams, but ADP is built to handle larger, more complex workforces.

Payroll complexity

Switch when payroll spans multiple states or countries. ADP handles multi-jurisdiction compliance, garnishments, and complex tax rules more easily.

HR maturity

Move when you need a full HRIS. ADP offers recruiting, performance, learning, and benefits administration that Gusto does not match at scale.

Frequently asked questions

Not sure which payroll platform fits your business?

Answer a few questions and Biz Match Match will recommend the right payroll or HR solution — Gusto, ADP, or one of the other providers we track — based on your team size, budget, and compliance needs.

Start free assessment